A Critical Response to “Persian Vowel Harmony Without Exceptionality: A Reply to Jam”

Document Type : Book Review

Author

Associate Professor, Department of English, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, Shahrekord University, Shahrekord, Iran.

Abstract

Critiquing research papers is an essential component of scholarly advancement, provided that it is undertaken meticulously, considering the relevant theoretical framework and adhering to professional and ethical decorum to avoid disrespecting researchers’ academic credibility. This rejoinder constitutes a response to the critique by Pirhayati (2025) concerning the present author’s paper entitled “Vowel Harmony in Persian,” published in Lingua in 2020. The issues that the critic discusses include comments on vowel harmony in the Persian imperative structures, particularly exceptionality, constraint rankings, prenasal raising, and the phonological representation of English loanwords in Persian, as well as some additional criticisms. The purpose of this rejoinder is to address all criticisms raised in that critique, providing detailed and scholarly responses to each point—with explicit reference to the topics discussed by the critic—in order to clarify the analyses presented in Jam (2020) and to dispel potential ambiguities

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

Calabrese, A., & Wetzels, W. L. (2009). Loan phonology: Issues and controversies. In A. Calabrese & W. L. Wetzels (Eds.), Loan phonology (pp. 1–10). John Benjamins Publishing Company.
Jam, B. (2017). An optimality-theoretic account of exceptionality & optionality in pre-nasal raising in Persian. Journal of Language Research, 7(2), 19–38. https://doi.org/10.22059/jolr.2016.61523 [in Persian]
Jam, B. (2019). Glottal stop in Persian. Persian Language and Iranian Dialects, 3(2), 73–92. https://doi.org/10.22124/plid.2019.11361.1310 [in Persian]
Jam, B. (2020). Vowel harmony in Persian. Lingua, 246, 1–25.
Kiparsky, P. (1973). Elsewhere in phonology. In S. R. Anderson & P. Kiparsky (Eds.), A festschrift for Morris Halle (pp. 93–106). Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
Pater, J. (2006). The locus of exceptionality: Morpheme-specific phonology as constraint indexation. In L. Bateman, M. O’Keefe, E. Reilly, & A. Werle (Eds.), Papers in optimality  theory III (pp. 259–296). GLSA.
Pater, J. (2008). Morpheme-specific phonology: Constraint indexation and inconsistency resolution. In S. Parker (Ed.), Phonological argumentation: Essays on evidence and motivation. Equinox.
Pirhayati, A. (2025). Persian vowel harmony without exceptionality: A reply to Jam [Review of the article Vowel harmony in Persian, by B. Jam, 2020]. Research in Western Iranian Languages and Dialects, 13(3), 103–108. https://doi.org/10.22126/jlw.2025.11065.1791
Sadeghi, A. (2001). Masaele Tarikhi-ye Zaban-e Farsi [Historical issues of Persian]. Sokhan. [In Persian]
Sloos, M. (2013). Phonological grammar and frequency: An integrated approach: Evidence from German, Indonesian and Japanese [Doctoral dissertation, University of Groningen]. University of Groningen Research Portal. https://doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.1.1720.1763
Tabibzadeh, O. (2021). A strange and repetitive mistake in phonological descriptions of Iranian dialects. Language and Linguistics, 17(34), 333–340. https://doi.org/10.30465/lsi.2022.8445 [in Persian] 
Research in Western Iranian Languages and Dialects
Volume 14, Issue 2
July 2026
Pages 95-104

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics